• About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Awards
Menu
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Awards
Facebook-f Twitter Youtube
  • HOME
  • Ireland/Europe
  • Eastern Partnership
  • Americas
  • Asia/Pacific
  • Africa/Middle East
  • Security
  • Climate
  • Interviews
  • About
Menu
  • HOME
  • Ireland/Europe
  • Eastern Partnership
  • Americas
  • Asia/Pacific
  • Africa/Middle East
  • Security
  • Climate
  • Interviews
  • About
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Awards
Menu
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Awards
Facebook-f Twitter Youtube


Helping You Understand the World
with Original Interviews, News
& Analysis from Ireland,
the EU and around the Globe

www.diplomacyireland.eu

DS 7 Long Image copy
  • HOME
  • Ireland/Europe
  • Eastern Partnership
  • Americas
  • Asia/Pacific
  • Africa/Middle East
  • Security
  • Climate
  • Interviews
  • About
Menu
  • HOME
  • Ireland/Europe
  • Eastern Partnership
  • Americas
  • Asia/Pacific
  • Africa/Middle East
  • Security
  • Climate
  • Interviews
  • About
Helping You Understand the World with Original Interviews, News & Analysis from Ireland, the EU and around the Globe www.diplomacyireland.eu
Keshk Square
Art of Coffee 500x500
Miena-Nougat-almondcoconutlemonhero
Soma 500x500
Airmid 500x500
Revolut Black 500x500
Wicklow Moinier 500x500
Holo Kombucha 500x500
Munster Mediation 500x500
Dublin Herbalists 500x500
Dublin Distillery 500x500
EPIC 500x500
Lucozade 500x500
Dingle Chocolates
Turkish Black 500x500
Britvic 500x500
Oriel New 500x500
Revolut White 500x500
Munster Brewery 500x500
Jeanie Johnston 500x500
Turkish White 500x500
Dublin Herbalist No2 500x500
Fantastic Flavours 500x500
Ribena Bottles 500x500
Ribena 500x500
Wrist Pocket 500x500
Milseologe
Inis Fragrance 500x500
Machado Beard Oil 500 x 500
Previous
Next
  • HOME
  • Ireland/Europe
  • Eastern Partnership
  • Americas
  • Asia/Pacific
  • Africa/Middle East
  • Security
  • Climate
  • Interviews
  • About
Menu
  • HOME
  • Ireland/Europe
  • Eastern Partnership
  • Americas
  • Asia/Pacific
  • Africa/Middle East
  • Security
  • Climate
  • Interviews
  • About
Home News & Analysis

Russian Forces Skilled Execution of Retreat from Kherson Signals Tough Times Ahead

New Russian Commander Shows Deft Tactical Moves – But Will it Be Enough?

Editor by Editor
16 November 2022
in News & Analysis, Security
0
0
SHARES
58
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

by Miceál O’Hurley

KHERSON — Few people with a shred of humanity could do anything but rejoice at the Russian evacuation of Kherson.  The wholesale carnage they could have inflicted on Ukrainian civilians and soldiers had they defended Kherson, making the Ukrainian Armed Forces fight for every inch of land on the West Bank of the Dniper, could have proved devastating.  As it is, the booby-traps and mines they left behind during their retreat—devices meant to indiscriminately kill Ukrainian civilians and military alike—will prove as devastating as they are cruel.  Add to that the Russian Federation forces’ barbaric and needless destruction of critical infrastructure that has left Ukrainians freezing, hungry, without electricity, heat or running water.

Albeit, Ukrainians are celebrating the liberation of Kherson even while they steel themselves for further combat to fully liberate their country from Russian invaders.  The combat operations to come may prove far more costly than conventional wisdom would indicate.  Moreover, it would require the coalition that supports the international rule of law and restoration of Ukraine’s territorial integrity to maintain is discipline if not increase the tempo and scope of its aid.

Contrary to some ill-informed pundits, Russia’s retreat from Kherson was entirely tactical and it came at a high political and social cost to the Russian Federation’s dwindling prestige and that of Vladimir Putin.  Still, the speed and discipline by which they achieved their retreat from this geographically key city leaves an old soldier like me feeling chills up-and-down his spine.  Evacuation across large, open, danger areas is always difficult.  This is especially true if it is a water-crossing operation.  Evacuations by even the most well-trained troops are always a bit helter-skelter.  There is a tendency for bridges to become clogged with traffic.  Ferries invariably experience problems.  The logistics of what equipment to bring and what to leave is always daunting.  Moreover, the order of withdrawl that ensures an orderly retreat while providing rear-guard defense is always a tricky call for a commander in the field. The peril during such operations is for troops and equipment to ‘bunch-up’ and leave themselves sitting targets for drones, artillery and usually air strikes.  That Russian forces successfully evacuated Kherson without losing scores of troops and evacuating most of their equipment while facing a ‘mini-Dunkirk’ ensnarement showed a discipline by them rarely seen this year.  To boot, it took place while significant numbers of new recruits are replenishing Russian battalions serving in Ukraine, including along the contact line with Kherson.  Needless to say, Russia’s success has caused some shock and awe amongst seasoned analysts.

The second observation of concern arises from Russia’s ability to execute another difficult task—a withdrawal-through-lines.  As Russian forces left Kherson and the West Bank of the Dniper they had no choice but to pass through their own lines manned by troops ready to repulse any pursuit or infiltration by Ukrainian forces.  This is always a difficult operation.  Keeping your own trigger-happy troops from engaging in a friendly-fire incident as they pass through lines requires not only discipline but luck.  Russia’s ability to execute a large scale withdrawal through-lines operation without reports of friendly-fire gives another reason for Ukraine to be en guard.  Russian forces, like the Nazi units that fought to defend territory in the waning days of World War II, might have just demonstrated they are more disciplined and capable than previously thought if only so by necessity.

Given Russia’s execution of these two highly difficult tactical maneuvers Western supporters of Ukraine must see the matter in context.  While Russia achieved a successful retreat it was nonetheless a retreat.  Accordingly, they should recognise it for what it is and redouble their efforts to ensure Ukraine maintains the momentum.  The best way to do this is by increasing the flow of critical weapons systems into Ukraine and ensuring the latest technology is made available in real-time.  While an analyst might begrudgingly admire the tactical success of the Russian evacuation they can only do so with the unequivocal acknowledgement that Russia is losing and losing badly.  This admission comes within the context of the realisation that Russia is still capable of inflicting great pain even while they retreat to an ever-shrinking occupation footprint within Ukraine.  The contact line remains long and with winter approaching Ukraine cannot afford to allow a stalemate of trench warfare to ensure with each side dug-in and pounding each other (and civilians) with artillery.

In the final analysis, as much as Russia might like to enjoy abundant credit for the success of their operation and claim Ukraine missed the opportunity to annihilate them as they attempted to retreat across the Dniper out of weakness and inexperience that would be folly.  Russia retreated.  Period.  Tactical or not – that is rarely good news for any army.

Ukraine’s commanders showed remarkable wisdom by allowing the Russian evacuation.  It was a pragmatic choice.  The Russian retreat allowed Ukraine to quickly regain territory with limited sacrifice.  Facing combat in an gruelling urban landscape Ukraine’s decision to allow Russians to cut-and-run was as cunning as it was practical.  Ukraine would have taken Kherson by force but now they have achileved the same goal without the wholesale bloodshed that would have occured.  The General Staff of the Ukraine Armed Forces acted to reserve their decision to fight on terrain more suited to their strengths and needs—a remarkably disciplines and wise choice.  This is hardly surprising.  Ukrainian commanders have out-generalled and their troops have out-soldiered Russian forces at every turn this year.  Nonetheless,  some measure of reticent respect for Russia’s execution of this difficult tactical operation might cause one to suspend their belief that Russia has expended its fighting capabilities.  It hasn’t and the road ahead will be costly and possibly long.

Western solidarity is essential.  This is especially so in light of Russian missiles raining down on Polish territory where the outcome of the meeting triggered by Article 4 of the NATO treaty might determine the outcome of a more direct involvement of some Western nations if the mutual defense aspect of Article 5 is triggered.  NATO must determine what restraint can be exercised and yet still maintain the mere threat of Article 5 being a deterent and in so doing risk an imbalance in the Western pact with non-NATO nations.

 

 

 

Tags: KhersonMiceal O'HurleyRussiaUkraine
Previous Post

Truth, Tehran and an Increasingly Dangerous World

Next Post

It is Folly to Expect Diplomatic Off-Ramps to Be Availed by Russia

Editor

Editor

Next Post
It is Folly to Expect Diplomatic Off-Ramps to Be Availed by Russia

It is Folly to Expect Diplomatic Off-Ramps to Be Availed by Russia

Stay Connected test

  • 23.8k Followers
  • 99 Subscribers
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Dr. Sasa – UN Envoy of the National Unity Government (Myanmar) to Receive Special Award

Dr. Sasa – UN Envoy of the National Unity Government (Myanmar) to Receive Special Award

10 December 2021
Friend, Activist and Humanitarian Dies – Martin Reuther, R.I.P.

Friend, Activist and Humanitarian Dies – Martin Reuther, R.I.P.

7 November 2021
His Excellency Mr. Ophir Kariv to Receive Diplomatic Service Medal with Honours

His Excellency Mr. Ophir Kariv to Receive Diplomatic Service Medal with Honours

14 November 2021
Is Ireland Undermining EU Sanctions Against Russia?

Is Ireland Undermining EU Sanctions Against Russia?

2 January 2023
Cycle of Bombings and Rocket Attacks Threaten JCPOA Progress – News & Analysis

Cycle of Bombings and Rocket Attacks Threaten JCPOA Progress – News & Analysis

0
Ireland Returns to Tehran – Minister Coveney Visits

Ireland Returns to Tehran – Minister Coveney Visits

0
Server Fire Necessitates Web Site Reconstruction

Server Fire Necessitates Web Site Reconstruction

0
Minister Byrne Holds Talks with Key Commissioners in Brussels on Covid-19 and Rule of Law

Minister Byrne meets with Ad-Hoc Group on North South and East West Cooperation

0
Netanyahu’s Attempts at Judicial Reform Result in Strikes and Air Travel Suspension

Netanyahu’s Attempts at Judicial Reform Result in Strikes and Air Travel Suspension

27 March 2023
Analysis: Chances of Diplomatic Solution Dissipate with Putin ICC Arrest Warrant

Analysis: Chances of Diplomatic Solution Dissipate with Putin ICC Arrest Warrant

20 March 2023
NAKO/IPHR Reports Supplies of Dual-Use Components Key to Weapons Flow Freely to Russia

NAKO/IPHR Reports Supplies of Dual-Use Components Key to Weapons Flow Freely to Russia

2 March 2023
Recean to Lead New Moldova Government as Prime Minister

Recean to Lead New Moldova Government as Prime Minister

16 February 2023

Recent News

Netanyahu’s Attempts at Judicial Reform Result in Strikes and Air Travel Suspension

Netanyahu’s Attempts at Judicial Reform Result in Strikes and Air Travel Suspension

27 March 2023
Analysis: Chances of Diplomatic Solution Dissipate with Putin ICC Arrest Warrant

Analysis: Chances of Diplomatic Solution Dissipate with Putin ICC Arrest Warrant

20 March 2023
NAKO/IPHR Reports Supplies of Dual-Use Components Key to Weapons Flow Freely to Russia

NAKO/IPHR Reports Supplies of Dual-Use Components Key to Weapons Flow Freely to Russia

2 March 2023
Recean to Lead New Moldova Government as Prime Minister

Recean to Lead New Moldova Government as Prime Minister

16 February 2023

│ Contact Details

Address

Diplomacy in Ireland - The European Diplomat
Miceal O'Hurley
16 Carleton Village Apartments
Youghal, Co. Cork P36 H213

Phone Number

Office: 01.254.4747 Editor: 086.107.0017

E-mail

editor@diplomacyireland.eu

Social Links

Facebook Twitter Youtube

│ Latest News

Battle for Myanmar’s Seat at UN Deferred by China-US Brokered Deal

New York City Mayor Collaborates with Secretary General on UN Vaccine Mandate – Russia Protests Amongst Collegiality by Others

Ireland’s September Presidency of the UNSC Has Daunting Programme – Afghanistan and Peacekeeping Tops List

Foreign Direct Investment in focus on ‘In Conversation This Week’ with Dan Bilak, Esq., Senior Counsel, Kinstellar – Leading Independent Law Firm in Emerging Europe, Turkey and Central Asia

Minister Byrne Welcomes the Publication of Eurofound’s Report on “Social Factors Shaping Optimism and Pessimism Among Citizens”

Battle for Myanmar’s Seat at UN Deferred by China-US Brokered Deal

Netanyahu’s Attempts at Judicial Reform Result in Strikes and Air Travel Suspension

Analysis: Chances of Diplomatic Solution Dissipate with Putin ICC Arrest Warrant

NAKO/IPHR Reports Supplies of Dual-Use Components Key to Weapons Flow Freely to Russia

Recean to Lead New Moldova Government as Prime Minister

Is Russia Provoking NATO and West with Airspace Violations?

│ Sitemap

Home
Ireland/European Union
Eastern Partnership (EaP)
Americas
Africa/Middle East
Asia/Pacific
Security
Climate
Interviews
VIdeos
About Us

│ Our GDPR Policy

Click Here to see our GDPR Privacy Policy

© Copyright 2020, All rights reserved.

Home
About
Diplomatic List
Contact