• About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Awards
Menu
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Awards
Facebook-f Twitter Youtube
  • HOME
  • Ireland/Europe
  • Eastern Partnership
  • Americas
  • Asia/Pacific
  • Africa/Middle East
  • Security
  • Climate
  • Interviews
  • About
Menu
  • HOME
  • Ireland/Europe
  • Eastern Partnership
  • Americas
  • Asia/Pacific
  • Africa/Middle East
  • Security
  • Climate
  • Interviews
  • About
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Awards
Menu
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Awards
Facebook-f Twitter Youtube


Helping You Understand the World
with Original Interviews, News
& Analysis from Ireland,
the EU and around the Globe

www.diplomacyireland.eu

DS 7 Long Image copy
  • HOME
  • Ireland/Europe
  • Eastern Partnership
  • Americas
  • Asia/Pacific
  • Africa/Middle East
  • Security
  • Climate
  • Interviews
  • About
Menu
  • HOME
  • Ireland/Europe
  • Eastern Partnership
  • Americas
  • Asia/Pacific
  • Africa/Middle East
  • Security
  • Climate
  • Interviews
  • About
Helping You Understand the World with Original Interviews, News & Analysis from Ireland, the EU and around the Globe www.diplomacyireland.eu
Keshk Square
Art of Coffee 500x500
Miena-Nougat-almondcoconutlemonhero
Soma 500x500
Airmid 500x500
Revolut Black 500x500
Wicklow Moinier 500x500
Holo Kombucha 500x500
Munster Mediation 500x500
Dublin Herbalists 500x500
Dublin Distillery 500x500
EPIC 500x500
Lucozade 500x500
Dingle Chocolates
Turkish Black 500x500
Britvic 500x500
Oriel New 500x500
Revolut White 500x500
Munster Brewery 500x500
Jeanie Johnston 500x500
Turkish White 500x500
Dublin Herbalist No2 500x500
Fantastic Flavours 500x500
Ribena Bottles 500x500
Ribena 500x500
Wrist Pocket 500x500
Milseologe
Inis Fragrance 500x500
Machado Beard Oil 500 x 500
Previous
Next
  • HOME
  • Ireland/Europe
  • Eastern Partnership
  • Americas
  • Asia/Pacific
  • Africa/Middle East
  • Security
  • Climate
  • Interviews
  • About
Menu
  • HOME
  • Ireland/Europe
  • Eastern Partnership
  • Americas
  • Asia/Pacific
  • Africa/Middle East
  • Security
  • Climate
  • Interviews
  • About
Home News & Analysis

UN Arbitration Committee to Consider Palestinian Charge of Israeli ‘Apartheid’

Editor by Editor
4 May 2021
in News & Analysis
0
0
SHARES
0
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

by Miceál O’Hurley
Diplomatic Editor

NEW YORK – Following a formal complaint by the Palestinian Authority, on Friday, 30 April 2021, a United Nations (UN) arbitrations committee will be empanelled to investigate the accusation that Israel has committed acts of apartheid.  The UN Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination (CERD) will assume responsibility for the enquiry.

Israel has been a Member of the UN since 1949.  In 2012, the Palestinians were granted ‘Non Member Observer Status’ by vote of the UN General Assembly.  Although not a member of the UN, the Secretary General has authorised the chief diplomat for the Palestinians to use the title ‘Permanent Observer Mission of the State of Palestine to the United Nations’ in a de facto recognition that the Palestinians should be treated as a State, replacing the former UN usage of Palestinian Authority.  In 2012, Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas was granted the dignity of being seated in the ‘beige chair’, an honour reserved for Heads of State.

Who is CERD and What Do They Do?
CERD is the UN monitoring body of the 1969 Convention on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination.  An 18-member body, it examines all UN States for compliance on a regular basis.  Israel has come under scrutiny by CERD previously, as have all States in the UN.  The last CERD enquiry was in 2019.  Israel has cooperated with all previous CERD enquiries.

Both Israel and the Palestinians are signatories to the Convention on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination which, under Article 3, strictly prohibits apartheid:

“States Parties particularly condemn racial segregation and apartheid and undertake to prevent, prohibit and eradicate all practices of this nature in territories under their jurisdiction.”

Problematic for this dispute is the utter lack of definition of ‘apartheid’ in the Convention.  Critics have charged that as with ‘genocide’, ‘apartheid’ carries a highly-charged, emotive connotation and shifting opinions about its definition leave the legal usage of ‘apartheid’ open to accusations of application for political purposes.

The Palestinians initially filed their complaint with CERD on 23 April 2018.  The issue was scheduled to be considered in 2020, however, the Covid-19 pandemic intervened and delayed CERD consideration.  The complaint charged that Israel is actively violating Articles 2, 3 and 5 of the convention through their actions in East Jerusalem, Gaza and the West Bank.

Momentum for Recognition of Israeli ‘Apartheid’
In 2017, a UN agency, Economic and Social Commission for Western Asia (ESCWA), published a report accusing Israel of imposing an “apartheid regime” of racial discrimination with regard to the Palestinian people.  The report was the first instance in which a UN body had clearly made the charge of “apartheid” with regard to Israel.  UN Under-Secretary General, and ESCWA Executive Secretary Rima Khalaf, called the report the “first of its type [from a UN body] clearly and frankly concludes that Israel is a racist state that has established an apartheid system that persecutes the Palestinian people.” 

Immediately following the report’s release, UN spokesman Stephane Dujarric told reporters in New York that the report was published “without any prior consultation with the U.N. Secretariat.”  Dujarric stated, “The report as it stands does not reflect the views of the Secretary-General (Antonio Guterres),” adding, “…the report itself notes that it reflects the views of the authors.”  Uniquely, the report was ordered withdrawn by the Secretary General after strenuous objections by Israel, the United States and others.  It is no longer available on the UN or ESCWA web site.  A request to the UN for a copy of the report by Diplomat Ireland has gone un-answered.

In 2020 the issue of Israeli “apartheid” arose again in the UN.  Under UN Economic and Social Council resolution 1996/31, the UN Secretary General received a Joint written statement submitted by Al-Haq, Law in the Service of Man, Al Mezan Centre for Human Rights, BADIL Resource Center for Palestinian Residency and Refugee Rights, Cairo Institute for Human Rights Studies, Defence for Children International, Habitat International Coalition, and Palestinian Centre for Human Rights, non-governmental organizations in special consultative status in which the accusation of Israel operating an “apartheid regime” with regard to the Palestinian people was used repeatedly.

Only last week, Human Rights Watch published a report, A Threshold Crossed

Israeli Authorities and the Crimes of Apartheid and Persecution, which again levelled the accusation of “apartheid” at Israel.  The report was widely hailed by advocates for the Palestinian people as well as senior diplomats from numerous Governments, but is widely criticised by Israel and its allies as lacking in both context and objectivity, relying on factual inaccuracies and failing to meet commonly understood use of the term “apartheid”.

CERD Action Meets with Israeli Rebuke and Palestinian Approval
Israel’s Mission to the UN in Geneva issued Israel’s initial response, after CERD indicated on Friday last it would advance the matter.  His Excellency Gilad Erdan, Israel’s chief diplomat to the UN, replied in a prepared statement saying, “[CERD] has applied discriminatory standards against Israel to justify its outrageous decision on the admissibility of the politically motivated Palestinian complaint.”

The news of CERD’s willingness to conduct and enquiry into the charge of Israeli “apartheid” was met with universal approval by the Palestinians and their allies.  In its own prepared statement, the Palestinian State asserted CERD’s willingness to further the matter on behalf of the UN was tantamount to a recognition that “Israel’s racism and discrimination against the Palestinian people violate the basic tenets of international law and humanity as a whole.”

UN Again Focal Point in Israeli-Palestinian Dispute
Given the UN arbitration committee’s willingness to examine the Palestinian’s complaint, the issue will once again place the UN in the midst of a long-running dispute between the Israelis and Palestinians.  Observers are keenly watching how traditional Palestinian advocates in the Middle East who have now signed the Abraham Accords with Israel, will react in the UN.  The move will also further distract United States President Joe Biden from his domestic agenda as the U.S. has been an unwavering ally of Israel and oft times a fierce critic of the UN.  Biden has gone to great pains to return the U.S. to multilateralism and shirk-off the mantle of isolationism that prevailed during the Trump era.

 

Tags: ApartheidArbitrationCERDESCWAIsraelMahmoud AbbasMiceal O'HurleyPalestinianSecretary GeneralUN
Previous Post

World Press Freedom Day 2021 – Journalists Urge Governments to Roll Back Media Restrictions

Next Post

Ireland Responds to COVID-19 Surge in India

Editor

Editor

Next Post
Minister Brophy to Participate in Generation Equality Forum, Mexico City

Ireland Responds to COVID-19 Surge in India

Stay Connected test

  • 23.8k Followers
  • 99 Subscribers
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Dr. Sasa – UN Envoy of the National Unity Government (Myanmar) to Receive Special Award

Dr. Sasa – UN Envoy of the National Unity Government (Myanmar) to Receive Special Award

10 December 2021
Friend, Activist and Humanitarian Dies – Martin Reuther, R.I.P.

Friend, Activist and Humanitarian Dies – Martin Reuther, R.I.P.

7 November 2021
His Excellency Mr. Ophir Kariv to Receive Diplomatic Service Medal with Honours

His Excellency Mr. Ophir Kariv to Receive Diplomatic Service Medal with Honours

14 November 2021
Is Ireland Undermining EU Sanctions Against Russia?

Is Ireland Undermining EU Sanctions Against Russia?

2 January 2023
Cycle of Bombings and Rocket Attacks Threaten JCPOA Progress – News & Analysis

Cycle of Bombings and Rocket Attacks Threaten JCPOA Progress – News & Analysis

0
Ireland Returns to Tehran – Minister Coveney Visits

Ireland Returns to Tehran – Minister Coveney Visits

0
Server Fire Necessitates Web Site Reconstruction

Server Fire Necessitates Web Site Reconstruction

0
Minister Byrne Holds Talks with Key Commissioners in Brussels on Covid-19 and Rule of Law

Minister Byrne meets with Ad-Hoc Group on North South and East West Cooperation

0
Analysis: Chances of Diplomatic Solution Dissipate with Putin ICC Arrest Warrant

Analysis: Chances of Diplomatic Solution Dissipate with Putin ICC Arrest Warrant

20 March 2023
NAKO/IPHR Reports Supplies of Dual-Use Components Key to Weapons Flow Freely to Russia

NAKO/IPHR Reports Supplies of Dual-Use Components Key to Weapons Flow Freely to Russia

2 March 2023
Recean to Lead New Moldova Government as Prime Minister

Recean to Lead New Moldova Government as Prime Minister

16 February 2023
Is Russia Provoking NATO and West with Airspace Violations?

Is Russia Provoking NATO and West with Airspace Violations?

10 February 2023

Recent News

Analysis: Chances of Diplomatic Solution Dissipate with Putin ICC Arrest Warrant

Analysis: Chances of Diplomatic Solution Dissipate with Putin ICC Arrest Warrant

20 March 2023
NAKO/IPHR Reports Supplies of Dual-Use Components Key to Weapons Flow Freely to Russia

NAKO/IPHR Reports Supplies of Dual-Use Components Key to Weapons Flow Freely to Russia

2 March 2023
Recean to Lead New Moldova Government as Prime Minister

Recean to Lead New Moldova Government as Prime Minister

16 February 2023
Is Russia Provoking NATO and West with Airspace Violations?

Is Russia Provoking NATO and West with Airspace Violations?

10 February 2023

│ Contact Details

Address

Diplomacy in Ireland - The European Diplomat
Miceal O'Hurley
16 Carleton Village Apartments
Youghal, Co. Cork P36 H213

Phone Number

Office: 01.254.4747 Editor: 086.107.0017

E-mail

editor@diplomacyireland.eu

Social Links

Facebook Twitter Youtube

│ Latest News

Battle for Myanmar’s Seat at UN Deferred by China-US Brokered Deal

New York City Mayor Collaborates with Secretary General on UN Vaccine Mandate – Russia Protests Amongst Collegiality by Others

Ireland’s September Presidency of the UNSC Has Daunting Programme – Afghanistan and Peacekeeping Tops List

Foreign Direct Investment in focus on ‘In Conversation This Week’ with Dan Bilak, Esq., Senior Counsel, Kinstellar – Leading Independent Law Firm in Emerging Europe, Turkey and Central Asia

Minister Byrne Welcomes the Publication of Eurofound’s Report on “Social Factors Shaping Optimism and Pessimism Among Citizens”

Battle for Myanmar’s Seat at UN Deferred by China-US Brokered Deal

Analysis: Chances of Diplomatic Solution Dissipate with Putin ICC Arrest Warrant

NAKO/IPHR Reports Supplies of Dual-Use Components Key to Weapons Flow Freely to Russia

Recean to Lead New Moldova Government as Prime Minister

Is Russia Provoking NATO and West with Airspace Violations?

Bellicose Lavrov Explicitly Threatens Moldova

│ Sitemap

Home
Ireland/European Union
Eastern Partnership (EaP)
Americas
Africa/Middle East
Asia/Pacific
Security
Climate
Interviews
VIdeos
About Us

│ Our GDPR Policy

Click Here to see our GDPR Privacy Policy

© Copyright 2020, All rights reserved.

Home
About
Diplomatic List
Contact