• About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Awards
Menu
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Awards
Facebook-f Twitter Youtube
  • HOME
  • Ireland/Europe
  • Eastern Partnership
  • Americas
  • Asia/Pacific
  • Africa/Middle East
  • Security
  • Climate
  • Interviews
  • About
Menu
  • HOME
  • Ireland/Europe
  • Eastern Partnership
  • Americas
  • Asia/Pacific
  • Africa/Middle East
  • Security
  • Climate
  • Interviews
  • About
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Awards
Menu
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Awards
Facebook-f Twitter Youtube


Helping You Understand the World
with Original Interviews, News
& Analysis from Ireland,
the EU and around the Globe

www.diplomacyireland.eu

DS 7 Long Image copy
  • HOME
  • Ireland/Europe
  • Eastern Partnership
  • Americas
  • Asia/Pacific
  • Africa/Middle East
  • Security
  • Climate
  • Interviews
  • About
Menu
  • HOME
  • Ireland/Europe
  • Eastern Partnership
  • Americas
  • Asia/Pacific
  • Africa/Middle East
  • Security
  • Climate
  • Interviews
  • About
Helping You Understand the World with Original Interviews, News & Analysis from Ireland, the EU and around the Globe www.diplomacyireland.eu
Keshk Square
Art of Coffee 500x500
Miena-Nougat-almondcoconutlemonhero
Soma 500x500
Airmid 500x500
Revolut Black 500x500
Wicklow Moinier 500x500
Holo Kombucha 500x500
Munster Mediation 500x500
Dublin Herbalists 500x500
Dublin Distillery 500x500
EPIC 500x500
Lucozade 500x500
Dingle Chocolates
Turkish Black 500x500
Britvic 500x500
Oriel New 500x500
Revolut White 500x500
Munster Brewery 500x500
Jeanie Johnston 500x500
Turkish White 500x500
Dublin Herbalist No2 500x500
Fantastic Flavours 500x500
Ribena Bottles 500x500
Ribena 500x500
Wrist Pocket 500x500
Milseologe
Inis Fragrance 500x500
Machado Beard Oil 500 x 500
Previous
Next
  • HOME
  • Ireland/Europe
  • Eastern Partnership
  • Americas
  • Asia/Pacific
  • Africa/Middle East
  • Security
  • Climate
  • Interviews
  • About
Menu
  • HOME
  • Ireland/Europe
  • Eastern Partnership
  • Americas
  • Asia/Pacific
  • Africa/Middle East
  • Security
  • Climate
  • Interviews
  • About
Home Ireland/Europe

Setting the Record Straight

Further Information on Chief of Staff - Russian Meeting

Editor by Editor
6 February 2022
in Ireland/Europe, News & Analysis, Security
0
0
SHARES
19
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

by Miceál O’Hurley

DUBLIN – On 23 January 2022, Diplomacy in Ireland – European Diplomat published a story, Mixed-Messaging from Ireland on European Unity & Security — News & Analysis under my by-line.  I am responsible for the content of that article.

In that article I wrote that the photograph of Defense Forces Chief of Staff, Lieutenant General Seán Clancy, was photographed with the Russian Military Attaché and the Russian Federation Ambassador to Ireland, His Excellency Yuriy Filatov.  I wrote that the photograph was “taken at the Russian Embassy“.

I must now clarify information that has only just come into my possession to set the record straight.  This is my responsibility as a journalist.

The photograph was taken at the Chief of Staff’s offices and not the Russian Embassy.  The occasion of the visit, I have only just been able to learn, was a long-scheduled, routine meeting between the Chief of Staff and one of the handful of military attaché that are present in Ireland – in this case, the Military Attaché of the Russian Federation.  I have further learned that it is customary during these routine visits for the Ambassador of the sending Embassy to accompany their military attaché on their first visit as a matter of long-standing protocol.

It is worth revisiting the actions (or in this case the inaction on the part of the Department of Foreign Affairs and Defense Forces Press Offices) that led to the discrepancies in my reporting and in other media sources.

It is my policy, and that of Diplomacy in Ireland – European Diplomat to be careful with sources and fact checking.  In writing this story I personally emailed both the Department of Foreign Affairs and the Defense Forces press offices for comment prior to publication.  I was directed by the Department of Foreign Affairs to seek answers to my questions from the Defense Forces.  I not only telephoned the Defense Forces Press Office but sent an email and text message as well.  This was stated in my article.  Out of an abundance of caution, given the seriousness of the issue, I took the exceptional step of delaying publication of the article to allow for a prompt response from the Defense Forces (breaking a story is not as important as getting it right).  While I did get a telephone call from their Press Office asking to to send an email (which I did – with the promise of a prompt reply), no reply was given until the following day, long after the story was published.

 [Extract for original article]

Ireland Declines to Clarify Russian Embassy Statement and Photograph
An email asking for comment from the Department of Foreign Affairs about the Chief of Staff engaging in bilateral relations dialogue and the international agenda with the Russian Ambassador, and questioning if the discussion of developing closer contacts between the Russian and Irish armed forces was on the agenda at a time when growing Russian combat forces are marshalling along Ukraine’s border.  The question remains did the meeting represent a change in policy undertaken with the knowledge and direction of the Minister for Foreign Affairs or not.  The question was re-directed to the Defense Forces Press Office.  A telephone request from Diplomacy in Ireland – European Diplomat asking for comment by the Defense Forces was returned at 1539hrs asking for a written request.  The written request was not answered at the time of publication some 18-hours later, despite a SMS follow-up.  I’m certain some young solicitor has advised the Government of the legal axiom, Qui tacet consentire videtur (silence equals consent).

I am satisfied that I was reasonable, prudent and responsible in attempting to gather information for the article and provided both the Department of Foreign Affairs and Defense Forces more than ample opportunity to respond to my several enquiries.  In over 30-years of working as a journalist, around the world, it is necessary to state for clarity that it has becomes too routine for Government press offices to simply ignore enquiries where there is a legitimate public interest.  Such practices are inherently detrimental to the transparency, openness, cooperation and responsibility to the public interest.  Of greater concern is that such practices of simply ignoring media requests, especially from credentialed journalists, has proven hazardous to the Government’s trust and reputation, for which the blame rests on their inability or refusal to communicate effectively with members of the media.

The world has long moved-on from the days where ‘stonewalling‘ is accepted or effective.  Eventually, the truth emerges and almost always because of a refusal to engage with the media in a responsible and professional manner.

As I wrote in the original article:

... By all accounts, General Clancy is a highly-respected, seasoned professional known for his good judgment, intellect and capabilities.  It is hard to imagine such a leader unwittingly falling prey to attending such a meeting then being photographed smiling at its conclusion while Europe is at the precipice of war.

My information about, and confidence in Lieutenant Genereal Clancy, remains the same.  I still have every belief that he is a man of good judgment, intellect and capabilities.  He retains my respect (and yes, admiration), and I believes deserves the public’s too.  He would not be the first person in history to have a photograph circulated that portrays something as ominous when it was not (the Russian Embassy’s attempt to bring discredit upon the Chief of Staff and mischaracterise the meeting much to their benefit is shameful).  Here, it is also worth reporting that at the time of the meeting, the Russian Federation Ambassador had not forewarned the Irish Government about their plans to hold naval exercises in Ireland’s Exclusive Economic Zone.  From all accounts now available, the Chief of Staff was not aprised of Russia’s plans, albeit it would be more than reasonble to believe Ambassador Filatov was aware of them when he met with General Clancy.

The timing of the meeting and photograph was extremely unfortunate, but was owing in no part to Lieutenant General Clancy.  True, many would have called-off such a meeting given Russia’s build-up of combat forces to threaten yet another invasion of Ukraine/  But, that was a judgment call and there is a legitimate argument to be made that it is better to have established the relationship with the Russian Federation Military Attaché sooner, rather than later.

I am more than happy to correct the record on information that has come to me by a member of the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Foreign Affairs and Defense.  The facts should and must be know.  It remains puzzling why this information had to come from a member of the Committee and was not provided b either the Department of Foreign Affairs or Defense Forces Press Offices who duty it is to work with journalist to ensure the truth will out.

I do regret that both the Chief of Staff and the Irish Government ‘took it on the chin‘ from myself and others in the media, not to mention numerous memes and social media post by the hoi polloi simply because of a misguided, lingering belief that they can pick-and-choose when or if they will respond to media requests.  Sadly, they have again done so by self-inflicted injury and the affair could have been entirely avoided with a simple response.  It seems to be a pattern throughout government over the years.

The saying goes, ‘Democracy Dies in Darkness‘.  It is the duty of the media to shine the light of day on matters of public importance.  Trying to keep the media in the dark simply sets-up an unnecessary adversarial relationship and is a disservice to the public interest.  It is incumbent on Government press offices to be more responsive or better yet, proactive with providing information, to avoid such situations continually arising.

Tags: Chief of StaffCorrectionDefense ForcesDFAGeneralIrelandMeetingMiceal O'HurleyRussiaSean Clancy
Previous Post

International Expert in Cybersecurity, Chuck Brooks, Joins Diplomacy in Ireland – European Diplomat Team

Next Post

Veteran Journalist Minaam Shah Joins Diplomacy in Ireland – European Diplomat Team

Editor

Editor

Next Post
Veteran Journalist Minaam Shah Joins Diplomacy in Ireland – European Diplomat Team

Veteran Journalist Minaam Shah Joins Diplomacy in Ireland - European Diplomat Team

Stay Connected test

  • 23.8k Followers
  • 99 Subscribers
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Dr. Sasa – UN Envoy of the National Unity Government (Myanmar) to Receive Special Award

Dr. Sasa – UN Envoy of the National Unity Government (Myanmar) to Receive Special Award

10 December 2021
Friend, Activist and Humanitarian Dies – Martin Reuther, R.I.P.

Friend, Activist and Humanitarian Dies – Martin Reuther, R.I.P.

7 November 2021
His Excellency Mr. Ophir Kariv to Receive Diplomatic Service Medal with Honours

His Excellency Mr. Ophir Kariv to Receive Diplomatic Service Medal with Honours

14 November 2021
Is Ireland Undermining EU Sanctions Against Russia?

Is Ireland Undermining EU Sanctions Against Russia?

2 January 2023
Cycle of Bombings and Rocket Attacks Threaten JCPOA Progress – News & Analysis

Cycle of Bombings and Rocket Attacks Threaten JCPOA Progress – News & Analysis

0
Ireland Returns to Tehran – Minister Coveney Visits

Ireland Returns to Tehran – Minister Coveney Visits

0
Server Fire Necessitates Web Site Reconstruction

Server Fire Necessitates Web Site Reconstruction

0
Minister Byrne Holds Talks with Key Commissioners in Brussels on Covid-19 and Rule of Law

Minister Byrne meets with Ad-Hoc Group on North South and East West Cooperation

0
Netanyahu’s Attempts at Judicial Reform Result in Strikes and Air Travel Suspension

Netanyahu’s Attempts at Judicial Reform Result in Strikes and Air Travel Suspension

27 March 2023
Analysis: Chances of Diplomatic Solution Dissipate with Putin ICC Arrest Warrant

Analysis: Chances of Diplomatic Solution Dissipate with Putin ICC Arrest Warrant

20 March 2023
NAKO/IPHR Reports Supplies of Dual-Use Components Key to Weapons Flow Freely to Russia

NAKO/IPHR Reports Supplies of Dual-Use Components Key to Weapons Flow Freely to Russia

2 March 2023
Recean to Lead New Moldova Government as Prime Minister

Recean to Lead New Moldova Government as Prime Minister

16 February 2023

Recent News

Netanyahu’s Attempts at Judicial Reform Result in Strikes and Air Travel Suspension

Netanyahu’s Attempts at Judicial Reform Result in Strikes and Air Travel Suspension

27 March 2023
Analysis: Chances of Diplomatic Solution Dissipate with Putin ICC Arrest Warrant

Analysis: Chances of Diplomatic Solution Dissipate with Putin ICC Arrest Warrant

20 March 2023
NAKO/IPHR Reports Supplies of Dual-Use Components Key to Weapons Flow Freely to Russia

NAKO/IPHR Reports Supplies of Dual-Use Components Key to Weapons Flow Freely to Russia

2 March 2023
Recean to Lead New Moldova Government as Prime Minister

Recean to Lead New Moldova Government as Prime Minister

16 February 2023

│ Contact Details

Address

Diplomacy in Ireland - The European Diplomat
Miceal O'Hurley
16 Carleton Village Apartments
Youghal, Co. Cork P36 H213

Phone Number

Office: 01.254.4747 Editor: 086.107.0017

E-mail

editor@diplomacyireland.eu

Social Links

Facebook Twitter Youtube

│ Latest News

Battle for Myanmar’s Seat at UN Deferred by China-US Brokered Deal

New York City Mayor Collaborates with Secretary General on UN Vaccine Mandate – Russia Protests Amongst Collegiality by Others

Ireland’s September Presidency of the UNSC Has Daunting Programme – Afghanistan and Peacekeeping Tops List

Foreign Direct Investment in focus on ‘In Conversation This Week’ with Dan Bilak, Esq., Senior Counsel, Kinstellar – Leading Independent Law Firm in Emerging Europe, Turkey and Central Asia

Minister Byrne Welcomes the Publication of Eurofound’s Report on “Social Factors Shaping Optimism and Pessimism Among Citizens”

Battle for Myanmar’s Seat at UN Deferred by China-US Brokered Deal

Netanyahu’s Attempts at Judicial Reform Result in Strikes and Air Travel Suspension

Analysis: Chances of Diplomatic Solution Dissipate with Putin ICC Arrest Warrant

NAKO/IPHR Reports Supplies of Dual-Use Components Key to Weapons Flow Freely to Russia

Recean to Lead New Moldova Government as Prime Minister

Is Russia Provoking NATO and West with Airspace Violations?

│ Sitemap

Home
Ireland/European Union
Eastern Partnership (EaP)
Americas
Africa/Middle East
Asia/Pacific
Security
Climate
Interviews
VIdeos
About Us

│ Our GDPR Policy

Click Here to see our GDPR Privacy Policy

© Copyright 2020, All rights reserved.

Home
About
Diplomatic List
Contact